Legend - Director's Cut (1985) ****

Revisiting the Director’s Cut of Legend (1985), it’s striking how differently the film plays from the US theatrical version (review). The story is largely the same and the edits aren’t always drastically different but Jerry Goldsmith’s lush orchestral score dramatically alters the atmosphere and mood of the film. 

The longer running time gives Legend more breathing room and in many scenes that proves really effective. The DC has a more timeless quality, and while I am incredibly appreciative that it exists (and likewise love it), I don’t feel that all of the extended/alternate scenes are necessary (nor necessarily make the film better). The extra screen time afforded to the character of Meg Mucklebones, along with some briefly extended moments between (Lord of) Darkness and “Goth Lili” are easily my favorite parts. Having grown up with the US theatrical cut of Legend though—it’s the version that I am accustomed to, the version that holds a special place in my heart, and the version I will always associate with the film. 

After rewatching both cuts that I’m familiar with in succession (there is a third International Cut available on a UK Blu-ray that I have yet to see), I may just take it upon myself to create my own fan edit that incorporates elements of the two (much like I did with 2001's Donnie Darko, which can be found here) some day. It would be really interesting to experience a version of Legend with a runtime somewhere in between the US theatrical and director’s cuts—one that features Tangerine Dream and Jerry Goldsmith’s music.